Nilay Patel interviews Mitch Glazer, CEO of the RIAA, who was involved in the Napster lawsuits and is now leading the music industry's fight against AI companies that train on copyrighted music and create deepfakes. The episode explores the shift from suing music fans to battling AI giants, the complexities of labeling AI-generated content, and the existential question of protecting human artistry in an era of zero-friction creation.
Summarized by Podsumo
Mitch Glazer describes how the RIAA has pivoted from suing individual music fans (during the Napster era) to now fighting AI companies, with fans and artists united against AI's use of their work without permission or compensation.
The conversation delves into the challenge of creating a new intellectual property right for voice and likeness (the No Fakes Act), balancing First Amendment concerns with the need to protect artists from deepfakes.
Glazer explains that AI-generated music labeling is crucial, but its success depends on distributors (like DistroKid) and platforms (like Spotify) cooperating, with consumer demand and policy pressure driving adoption.
He argues that copyright's core purpose is to incentivize human creativity, and AI that substitutes for human-made music threatens the economic viability of artists and the cultural value of authentic human expression.
The RIAA is using litigation (e.g., its case against Suno) to establish that training AI on copyrighted music without consent is not fair use, seeking to secure basic rights so market negotiations can follow.
"The authenticity and that connection between a human being, an artist, and a fan, the preservation of that seems to be paramount in everything that we're doing."
— Mitch Glazer
"If non-human music, which can be made in two seconds without lived experience, and in my view without a soul, can dilute or drown out the incentives for people to be able to make a living as humans making art... what happens to our culture?"
— Mitch Glazer
"You can win the case but lose the business. Music is such a driver of a platform like YouTube that having pristine copies... and partnerships with people who invest with creators is irreplaceable."
— Mitch Glazer