This episode explores the connection between housing policy and falling fertility rates, arguing that restrictive zoning and high housing costs make it harder for young people to form families. The show examines how cities like Austin are reforming land use regulations to build more affordable housing, which could help increase birth rates. Experts discuss the trade-offs between NIMBYism and YIMBYism, the role of private equity in housing markets, and policy solutions to boost housing supply and family formation.
Summarized by Podsumo
The U.S. has 15 million fewer housing units than it would have if building rates had kept pace with historical trends, contributing to a severe affordability crisis.
Austin, Texas, reformed its permitting process (reducing steps from 1,500 to ~28 days) and cut minimum lot sizes from 5,750 to 1,800 square feet to boost housing supply and lower rents below national median.
Economist Ed Glaeser argues that zoning restrictions act as a 'zoning tax,' adding enormous costs to housing, especially in high-demand areas like Manhattan where building a new condo costs twice as much as construction.
Demographer Lyman Stone links housing to fertility: homeownership provides 'marriage insurance' and a long-term asset that makes childbearing more feasible, while restrictive zoning limits family-sized homes.
The podcast notes that remote work (27% of U.S. workdays) has shifted housing demand to suburbs, potentially increasing fertility due to more space, but also pushing up house prices.
"I always think when people are buying houses, they're better off thinking about themselves as purchasing the stage on which they will live their lives rather than on making a clever financial decision."
— Ed Glaeser
"The beauty of Austin has always been that it's had what I refer to as a fountain of youth. If we're not providing young people the avenue to stay, if we're not affordable, then they're going to quit coming or they're not going to stay, and Austin will lose that weirdness, that creativity."
— Mayor Kirk Watson
"There is something wonderfully irrational about fertility, in the sense that it's both the thing that has given me the most satisfaction in my life, but also certainly the most pain."
— Ed Glaeser