This HBR IdeaCast episode features Professor Vikas Mittal from Rice University, who discusses his seven-year study revealing that executives consistently fail to understand what customers truly value. The key insight is that leaders often rely on intuition and customer anecdotes, which leads to misaligned strategies, while statistical models can accurately identify the value drivers that matter most.
Summarized by Podsumo
Executives are almost always wrong when predicting what creates customer value, even when they have data and years of experience, due to overriding data with intuition.
Customers can tell you what they want but not what they truly value; for example, many want a gym in an apartment complex but fewer than 20% use it, while issues like maintenance create more value.
A statistical model that predicts customer value from survey data is similar to Netflix's algorithm—the difference is that Netflix doesn't override its algorithm with executive committees every quarter.
Companies that align strategy with data-driven value drivers see significant improvements: ITI's stock price increased 160% versus the S&P's 35% after focusing on rapid quoting.
The biggest impediment is lack of humility; executives often say 'you don't understand our business' even when their correlation of value drivers is zero or negative.
"Executives more or less are always wrong in terms of predicting what creates value for customers. They're good at telling you what customers say they want, which is different than what creates value for customers."
"A statistical model that predicts customer value from survey data is in principle no different from the algorithms Netflix uses. The difference is that Netflix doesn't convene a committee of experts to override its algorithm every quarter."
"If you can just walk them off that ledge and just say, look, there are ways to figure out what value drivers are and prioritize them, that's all it takes."