The Core Report

#833 Why India Still Does Not Set Global Agri Commodity Prices | Govindraj Ethiraj | The Core Report

32 min

The podcast explores why India, despite being a major agricultural producer and consumer, struggles to set global agri commodity prices. It highlights the National Commodity and Derivatives Exchange (NCDX)'s role in domestic price discovery and hedging, the impact of geopolitical events like wars on commodity markets, and the challenges posed by government bans on derivative trading. NCDX is also expanding its offerings into equities and weather derivatives to broaden its market impact and leverage its expertise.

Summarized by Podsumo

🎧 Listen 🎙️ Ask about this episode

✨ Key Takeaways

1

Geopolitical Shocks: Wars significantly impact commodity markets by causing shipment delays, increasing banking costs and insurance premiums, affecting perishable goods, and threatening food security and fertilizer supplies.
2

India's Price-Taking Status: Unlike China, where government agencies trade on exchanges, Indian government procurement systems don't utilize exchanges, hindering market-driven price discovery and preventing India from becoming a global price setter for commodities like pepper and edible oils.
3

NCDX's Role & Regulation: NCDX facilitates price discovery for farmers and hedging for corporates. SEBI regulations (stock limits, margins, position limits) prevent market manipulation, ensuring price movements are based on fundamentals rather than cartelization.
4

Strategic Diversification: NCDX is expanding beyond agriculture into equities (launching a mutual fund platform targeting rural investors through FPOs) and weather derivatives (developing a rainfall index with IIT Bombay for hedging against climate risks).
5

Critique of Commodity Bans: Bans on commodity derivatives are criticized as "shooting the messenger," as futures markets provide crucial forward price signals that enable governments to make informed decisions on imports or other interventions, rather than causing inflation.

💬 Notable Quotes

"So if you are shooting the messenger you are killing yourself. In fact, we are enablers."
"Dalian is about 150 times bigger than us. For the simple reason, that FCI or NAFED equivalent in China, they trade on exchange. In India, the government agencies don't trade on exchange."
"We are the largest producer but unfortunately our contracts went out and if you don't have a contract but somebody can take advantage of their situation and start a good contract somewhere else."